The Case for Public Relations vs. Advertising

By Donald Levin, APR, Fellow PRSA,
Levin Public Relations & Marketing, Inc., White Plains, NY

Most communications programs require all three elements of the marketing mix:  public relations, advertising and sales promotion. However, for budgetary and other reasons you may have to favor one element over another. Here’s the case for PR as opposed to advertising.

Studies prove that readers believe the publicity portion of PR (articles and news stories) far more often than they believe advertising. Part of the reason is third party endorsement: the magazine or other media is telling your story for you, you’re not doing it directly.

For equal dollars, publicity can appear in more publications with much greater circulation than advertising. One news story can appear in hundreds of media.

While ad space and time are purchased, no dollars or favors are given to reporters — you can’t buy publicity. Publicity experts earn media coverage by professional presentation of newsworthy material.

Many products and causes are launched — and sustained — through PR alone, without any advertising.

Production costs for publicity are far less than for advertising.

Aspects of PR beyond publicity also offer benefits over advertising: strategic public action, tie-ins to causes, speechmaking, letter writing campaigns, lobbying, advisory boards, charitable contributions, etc.

PR is a strong opportunity to combat larger competitors who have more advertising dollars.

The trend in marketing dollar allocations in America is toward PR.

If you have diverse markets and therefore a wide variety of media aimed at prospects, you can reach these targets more economically through PR.

Key executives build their industry presence through PR, specifically through by-lined articles, being quoted in news stories in prestigious media, and making speeches at top conferences.

PR provides opportunities to outshine and even “knock” competitors without seeming negative.

PR can stand alone in programs with no advertising. However, every ad campaign should be preceded and accompanied by PR, to support and extend the advertising message.

Advertising can cheapen the image of doctors, lawyers, financial planners and other professionals.

Newsletters and certain magazines are entirely editorial — platforms for PR not open to advertising.

PR is more factual since editors control their text. Advertising messages are couched in flowery adjectives.

To balance the above, let’s state that only with advertising can you buy as much as you want, when you want, in specific media, and with the exact text and graphics you desire. Still, for the above reasons, most companies and organizations should take full advantage of PR opportunities. Those who don’t (and those who rely on advertising instead) put themselves at a competitive disadvantage. The ideal is the appropriate mix of PR and advertising.   

 

back to top