|
How
to Hire a PR Firm
If you are
in the market for a public relations agency, choosing the firm that
is right for you involves several important steps and considerations.
First, evaluate
your own company's needs to clarify why you want further support.
You must fully understand what a PR firm can do for you, how public
relations differs from advertising and marketing, and how they impact
one another.
Second,
you must explore different options within your budget. It is essential
that your PR firm be a partner, not a vendor. You should research
the staff and company history, and narrow your selections based
on experience and chemistry. Take time to explore each agency's
strengths, weaknesses and proven capabilities. Agencies vary in
size, experience, and fee structure. Determining which agency best
fits your needs, budget, and style is crucial to a productive relationship.
Third, you
must be able to agree on reasonable expectations and the plans to
reach them. These plans should be specific but flexible. PR and
marketing strategies change, and unexpected opportunities will arise.
Fourth,
you must fully understand how PR firms work. For example, to be
successful, they should not merely work for you, but with you.
Finally,
learn how to get the most from your new representatives, and how
to measure the results of their activity.
1. Your
Needs
To determine
you company's need for outside help, the first question is: Why
do you need a public relations agency? Perhaps your opportunities
are great and your staff is small. Put another way, your company
simply wants one of three common goals of PR programs: to increase
sales, create strategic relationships, and help raise capital or
go public. Or your program is hampered by target audience misconceptions
or lack of awareness.
Know what
PR firms do and what they can do for you. Externally, they can improve
your relationships with prospective customers, your distribution
network, the financial world, government and the community at large.
Within your organization, better communications can boost employee
morale and productivity. A public relations firm will provide you
with objectivity, creativity, experience and extra hands to do the
job.
Among the
services a PR agency can provide are research, strategy, publicity,
marketing communications, special events, publications, web enhancement,
trade, technical, and investor relations, consumer and environmental
affairs, government and international relations, and institutional
advertising. Also, an agency can help with salesperson and speaker
training, speechwriting and platform development, crisis communications,
corporate identity and issues management.
PR firms
can also "close the sale": They can build on the excitement created
through your advertising techniques by enhancing, deepening and
broadening the reputation of your company. PR also greatly influences
"word of mouth" and can help regulate rumors or uncertainties about
your company.
2. Shopping
for PR
Start by
making a list of three to five firms recommended by colleagues,
trade associations, and public relations or web directories. Call
the companies for brochures and look up their websites for a feel
of how they present their capabilities.
Experience,
Experience, Experience. The PR staff working on your account must
grasp your business and your media immediately. Within "experience,"
we include "creativity" and "caring." Are the account executives
going to give you a stream of new ideas? Does the owner really want
the business? Does the staff have the experience to appreciate what
it doesn't know and has to learn?
During the
shopping period, avoid "new business" experts (salespeople); deal
instead with the account executive who would be responsible for
your organization. Not the agency principals — they can talk their
way into anything — but the people who will be writing your material
and pitching it to working reporters. They're the staff you have
to evaluate. The size of the agency means little; the "'people"
aspect is far more important. Who will be working on your account?
How much of their time will you get? Do you feel comfortable with
them?
In addition,
look for a firm that's growing and has clients whose businesses
are similar in size and character to your own. Looking at current
clients and work will give you a more accurate idea of what the
firm will do for you. Some companies put emphasis on media contacts,
yet their contacts are always changing because the turnover is so
high. Consistency with the media and placements are more important.
Take a look at the agency's past client list. Phone a few of them
and ask their opinion. You might even call former clients to learn
why they terminated their relationship.
Remember:
you're not hiring an ad agency. A public relations firm is different;
for one thing, the publicity function is based on earning space
and time through professional media relations while ad agencies
buy space and time, and fill it with whatever they create.
Some people
recommend getting competitive bids, but beware: agencies may present
dog-and-pony shows — dramatic fluff, not practical day-to-day reality.
Ask for a written proposal. Avoid glitz and glamorous slide presentations.
Go with facts, creativity and substance.
3. Budgeting
and Planning
A supervisor
or account executive will work with your firm on a daily basis to
develop specific plans and budgets, to implement plans, report results,
evaluate and suggest follow-up.
A firm has
one thing to sell — time. It sells staff time, just as a legal or
accounting firm does. You can buy this time in several ways:
Monthly
Fee: A monthly fee for services, generally based on an estimate
of all the work your organization might need.
Per Project:
A project fee for a product introduction, plant dedication, press
event or other special activity.
Retainer:
Hourly charges for staff time. Often, agencies use this method with
a minimum monthly fee. Sometimes these three arrangements are combined.
In any case, set aside 15 percent of your budget for unexpected
opportunities.
Out-of Pockets:
Costs for out-of-pocket expenses, such as long-distance phone bills,
printing, entertainment and photography, will be added to time charges,
some times with a mark-up of 17.65 percent or 20 percent for handling
and billing.
4. How
It Works, Handling Expectations:
The most
common PR tools are publicity, speaking engagements, brochures and
other materials, and special events (trade shows, seminars, open
houses, user groups, etc.) Your PR firm has expertise in these areas,
but its most important contribution will be strategic thinking —
creating new programs or messages that add a whole new dimension
to meeting your goals. Do not expect too much too soon for too little.
The behind-the-scenes work is far more extensive than you realize.
Let the
agency know your thinking early so they can contribute ideas before
you finalize your plans or budgets.
Be aware
of the long lead times for important publications (over six months);
publicity usually takes much longer to materialize than outsiders
expect.
On the subject
of time, determine how much of their work will require your supervision.
Ask how much time this might involve. Use the full range of your
agency's communications experience. Publicity may be at the heart
of your interest, but it's only a small portion of the services
you can profit from. Encourage the agency to advise you on strategy.
Consider
your public relations team as part of your management team. Expect
them to initiate action, be resourceful and attentive, and know
your business, industry and marketplace.
Benefit
from your PR firm's candid advice; allow them to serve as your critic
and to raise your level of expectation.
5. What
You'll Get for Your Money:
Public relations
is a wonderful opportunity, partly because the field is still largely
unexploited. An assertive company will get its moneysworth several
times over.
The firm
will carry out an agreed-upon plan. Your job is to provide continual
input and monitoring, to ensure that the work is on target and within
budget.
You can
measure the publicity part of the program quantitatively, by counting
clippings or inquiries. To evaluate your overall program is to simply
apply good management practice, evaluating a public relations service
the way you would your legal, accounting or architectural service.
How does the firm report progress? Do you have regular meetings
with them to assess action, objectives and results? Is the account
staff professional?
Above all,
keep your public relations firm informed about your developments
every day or week. And be perfectly honest; tell them how you feel
about their performance. Daily contact is important.
Hiring
a PR Firm: A Five-Point Checklist
1. Define
public relations objectives. An objective is more sales inquiries
or inclusion in analyst reports. An objective is an "end"; the means
to the end is strategy/tactics.
2. Understand
what outside help you need to achieve these objectives.
3. Before
interviewing, list the information you need to make your choice
as well as information the prospective firm should have to prepare
its case including:
Audiences you
want to reach (your markets),
Past and current
efforts that could affect the relationship,
A rough budget
guideline, and
Examples of
work for similar objectives and audiences.
4. Learn
the PR agency's account-management process and quality-assurance
procedures.
5. Do not
confuse how good the agency is in pitching for new business with
how well it will serve your needs. Ideal presentations by prospective
firms are informal discussions that illustrate their ways of thinking
and capabilities, not formalized, sophisticated presentations.
|
How Criteria Change
|
| Factors companies consider when choosing a PR
firm |
|
Factors companies use to evaluate
an existing firm.
|
| 1. Quality
of work |
|
1. Quality of work
|
| 2. Research Capabilities |
|
2. Deadlines/ promises
|
| 3. Client service |
|
3. Quality of account team
|
| 4. Creativity |
|
4. Client service
|
| 5. Chemistry |
|
5. Attention to detail
|
| 6. Measurable
results |
|
6. Honest/ accurate billing
|
| 7. Global capabilities |
|
7. Writing quality
|
| 8. Stability of
staff |
|
8. Creativity
|
| 9. Deadlines/promises |
|
9. Knowledge of my industry
|
| 10. Writing quality |
|
10. Strategic counsel
|
Source: A study
by A.C.Croft & Associates, February 1999
|
Suggestion: Factors to
Rank When Considering a PR Firm
| Experience |
Relative Weight
(0.1 to 1.0) |
x |
Score
(1-10) |
= |
Weighted Score |
| Years in business |
|
|
|
|
|
| Type of experience |
|
|
|
|
|
| Stature in PR industry |
|
|
|
|
|
| Access to top editors |
|
|
|
|
|
| Related accounts and results |
|
|
|
|
|
| Level of client service |
|
|
|
|
|
| Account supervisor experience |
|
|
|
|
|
| Account executive experience |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
Competency
|
Relative Weight
(0.1 to 1.0) |
x |
Score
(1-10) |
= |
Weighted Score |
| Industry knowledge |
|
|
|
|
|
| Specialized services |
|
|
|
|
|
| Media placements and relationships |
|
|
|
|
|
| Creativity/flexibility/"The Big Idea" |
|
|
|
|
|
| Teamwork/organization |
|
|
|
|
|
| Stability of firm and
staff |
|
|
|
|
|
| Timetable |
|
|
|
|
|
| Writing skills |
|
|
|
|
|
| Strategic counsel |
|
|
|
|
|
| Internet capabilities
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Financial/Business
|
Relative Weight
(0.1 to 1.0) |
x |
Score
(1-10) |
= |
Weighted Score |
| Size of firm |
|
|
|
|
|
| Cost of services |
|
|
|
|
|
| Methods of reporting results |
|
|
|
|
|
| Ability to stay within
budget |
|
|
|
|
|
| Avoids overpromising |
|
|
|
|
|
| Partner not vendor |
|
|
|
|
|
| Chemistry |
|
|
|
|
|
| Reference check |
|
|
|
|
|
| Total
Weighted Score |
|
|
back to top
|